The 15 Most Infamous Unsolved Mysteries of All Time (That Still Haunt Us Today)

Why do unsolved mysteries keep us captivated for decades? Which famous unsolved mysteries still haunt true crime fans today?

Why We’re Hooked on Unsolved Mysteries

Raise your hand if you’ve ever binge-watched Unsolved Mysteries, got chills listening to a true crime podcast, or found yourself Googling “famous cold cases that remain unsolved” at 1 a.m. You’re not alone—in fact, that fascination is baked into our psychology. We love mysteries because our brains crave closure. Psychologists point out that true crime and mysteries engage strong emotions and a lack of closure can fuel curiosity and obsession. That itch to resolve uncertainty is a big reason cases linger in our heads long after the headlines fade. Psychology Today

True crime fans love a puzzle. Not because there’s “fun” in tragedy, but because unanswered questions spark curiosity, empathy, and a very human need to make sense of chaos.

When a case goes cold, the questions multiply. Who was really responsible? Could you be the clever amateur detective who notices what professionals missed? That’s where DIY Detective steps in: bridging real-life crime curiosity with puzzles, trivia, and creative activity that put you in the investigator’s seat.

When the case files are open, the facts are on the table, and yet…the answers just aren’t there. That’s what makes unsolved mysteries so gripping. Unlike solved cases, there’s no neat ending, no courtroom confession, no DNA match that ties it all together. Instead, we’re left with theories, suspects, and endless “what ifs.” And maybe that’s why these stories stick with us.

Some of these mysteries are over a century old, others unfolded in our own lifetime. They’ve baffled police, stumped experts, and inspired waves of amateur detectives who can’t stop digging for answers. Let’s take a closer look at 15 of the most famous unsolved mysteries that continue to fascinate — and frustrate — true crime fans around the world.

1. Jack the Ripper

London, 1888. The city’s East End was already notorious for poverty and crime, but the Whitechapel murders pushed it into infamy. At least five women — Mary Ann Nichols, Annie Chapman, Elizabeth Stride, Catherine Eddowes, and Mary Jane Kelly — were brutally killed within a few months. The press gave the unknown killer a name: Jack the Ripper.

The murders were shocking not just for their brutality but for the taunting letters sent to newspapers and police. Whether the letters were authentic or written by journalists hoping to sell papers is still debated. What we do know is that police chased countless leads, from local butchers to foreign sailors, but never nailed down a suspect.

Over the years, theories have pointed to everyone from a member of the royal family to a well-known painter. Books and television specials keep recycling new suspects, but the truth is likely lost to history. Jack the Ripper remains one of the most enduring mysteries in true crime.

2. The Zodiac Killer

Fast forward to late 1960s California. A series of murders around the San Francisco Bay Area set off panic. The killer, who called himself the Zodiac, taunted police and newspapers with letters full of coded messages and bizarre symbols.

The Zodiac claimed responsibility for at least five murders between 1968 and 1969, though he hinted the number was much higher. His victims seemed to have no clear connection, which made the case even harder to crack. Some of his ciphers have been solved, including one in 2020 by a team of amateur codebreakers, but the messages don’t reveal his identity.

Over the decades, countless suspects have been floated, from schoolteachers to convicted criminals. Some amateur sleuths believe they’ve cracked it, but law enforcement has never confirmed a suspect with hard evidence. To this day, “Who was the Zodiac Killer?” remains one of the most asked questions in true crime circles.

3. The Black Dahlia Murder

Los Angeles, January 1947. A local woman walking in a vacant lot discovered the body of 22-year-old Elizabeth Short. The press quickly dubbed her “The Black Dahlia,” inspired by her dark clothing and a movie that had recently hit theaters.

The brutality of the crime stunned even seasoned investigators. Short’s body had been carefully posed, and the killer left no clear trace of who they were. The LAPD interviewed hundreds of people, and theories swirled around Hollywood hopefuls, mobsters, and even a doctor who some say matched the surgical precision of the crime.

The case has become legend, inspiring books, films, and endless speculation. While the LAPD still considers it an open case, it’s highly unlikely the killer will ever be identified. The Black Dahlia murder remains one of America’s most infamous unsolved crimes.

4. The Disappearance of Madeleine McCann

In May 2007, three-year-old Madeleine McCann vanished from a holiday apartment in Praia da Luz, Portugal. Her parents had left her sleeping while they dined nearby with friends. When they returned, she was gone.

The case became one of the most publicized missing child cases in the world. Suspects ranged from opportunistic kidnappers to local residents, and for a time, even Madeleine’s parents came under suspicion. Despite massive international coverage, multiple investigations, and countless supposed sightings, Madeleine has never been found.

In recent years, German authorities identified a convicted sex offender as a key suspect, but no charges have stuck. The McCann case continues to fuel debates about media coverage, parental responsibility, and the challenges of international policing.

5. The Somerton Man (NOW SOLVED!)

Australia, 1948. A well-dressed man was found dead on Somerton Beach near Adelaide. No ID, no signs of struggle, and no cause of death determined. All he had was a scrap of paper tucked in his pocket with the words “Tamám Shud” (Persian for “it is finished”).

Investigators traced the phrase back to a book of poetry, which led to a local nurse — but her connection to the man was never clear. Theories ranged from Cold War espionage to a simple undiagnosed medical issue.

In 2022, after decades of speculation, researchers using forensic genealogy were able to determine the man was a Melbourne electrical engineer named Carl Webb. While this could close the case, questions still linger about how he ended up on that beach and why no one reported him missing.

6. The Disappearance of Amelia Earhart

In 1937, aviation pioneer Amelia Earhart set out to fly around the world. Somewhere over the Pacific Ocean, her plane disappeared. Despite one of the largest search efforts of its time, neither Earhart nor her navigator, Fred Noonan, were ever found.

Theories about her fate abound. Some say she crashed into the ocean, others argue she landed on a remote island and died as a castaway. Conspiracy theories even claim she was captured by the Japanese or assumed a new identity in the U.S.

What keeps the case alive is the lack of closure. Every few years, expeditions return to the Pacific to search for wreckage or evidence, but nothing definitive has been uncovered. Earhart’s disappearance is not just a mystery — it’s part of the fabric of American history.

7. The Isdal Woman

Norway, 1970. Hikers discovered the charred body of a woman in a remote valley known as Isdalen. Around her were personal items with the labels removed, and an autopsy revealed a mix of sleeping pills and carbon monoxide poisoning.

When police dug deeper, they found multiple fake passports and evidence she had traveled across Europe using different identities. Despite an extensive investigation, her true name and purpose remain unknown.

Theories range from Cold War spy games to a woman seeking to disappear by choice. Decades later, journalists and podcasters continue to investigate, but the Isdal Woman remains one of Europe’s most chilling unsolved mysteries.

8. The Disappearance of Malaysia Airlines Flight MH370

In March 2014, Malaysia Airlines Flight MH370 vanished from radar with 239 people on board. Despite one of the most extensive searches in aviation history, the wreckage has never been fully located.

Small pieces of debris have washed up on beaches around the Indian Ocean, but they don’t provide answers about why the plane went off course. Did the pilot take control in a suicide mission? Was it a catastrophic technical failure? Or something else entirely?

The disappearance sparked endless theories online, some reasonable, others far-fetched. Nearly a decade later, families are still without answers, and MH370 has become one of the greatest mysteries of modern aviation.

9. The Hinterkaifeck Murders

Germany, 1922. On a small farmstead called Hinterkaifeck, six members of the Gruber family were murdered with a mattock (a farming tool). The killer then stayed on the property for several days, tending livestock and eating meals while the bodies lay in the house.

Neighbours reported strange events leading up to the murders: footprints in the snow leading to the house but not away, mysterious noises in the attic, and a set of house keys that had gone missing.

Theories range from a disgruntled neighbour to a vagrant, or even one of the family members themselves. Despite interviewing over 100 suspects, police never solved the case. The Hinterkaifeck murders remain one of Germany’s darkest unsolved crimes.

10. The Mystery of D.B. Cooper

In 1971, a man known only as “Dan Cooper” (misreported as D.B. Cooper) hijacked a commercial flight from Portland to Seattle. He claimed he had a bomb and demanded $200,000 in ransom. After receiving the money, he parachuted from the plane and vanished.

Despite years of investigation by the FBI, Cooper was never identified or found. A few pieces of the ransom money were discovered buried along a riverbank in Washington State, but that’s the only trace.

Theories suggest he may have died during the jump, or that he survived and lived quietly under a new identity. Cooper has become something of a folk legend — the outlaw who pulled off the only unsolved hijacking in U.S. history.

11. The Dyatlov Pass Incident

Investigators examining a tent found at Dyatlov Pass, cut open from the inside. Image: public domain via Wikimedia Commons

In 1959, nine experienced hikers set off into the Ural Mountains in Soviet Russia. Only one returned. The others were later found dead under bizarre circumstances: tents slashed open from the inside, bodies scattered across the snow, some missing clothing, and a few with injuries more in line with a car crash than exposure to the cold.

Theories came fast — an avalanche, a military cover-up, infrasound that drove them into a panic, or even extraterrestrials. The truth remains elusive. In 2019, Russian authorities officially concluded an avalanche was to blame, but many experts and armchair sleuths remain unconvinced. Something about the details just doesn’t add up, and that’s why the Dyatlov Pass incident still sparks debate more than sixty years later.

12. The Disappearance of Jimmy Hoffa

Jimmy Hoffa was one of the most powerful labor leaders in the United States. As president of the Teamsters Union, he had connections to organized crime, politicians, and big business. But in 1975, Hoffa vanished after heading to a meeting outside Detroit.

Despite countless searches — including digging up fields, draining lakes, and even tearing apart stadiums — Hoffa’s body has never been found. Theories suggest he was killed by the mob to silence him, or that rival union figures took him out. The FBI considers the case open, but with so much time passed, the odds of solving it are slim.

Hoffa’s disappearance has become part of American lore. Every few years, someone claims to know where he’s buried, but no credible evidence has ever turned up.

13. The Tylenol Murders

In 1982, seven people in the Chicago area died after taking Tylenol capsules that had been laced with cyanide. The deaths sparked nationwide panic and led to the recall of more than 30 million bottles of Tylenol.

The case changed consumer safety forever. It’s the reason we now have tamper-proof seals on medicine and food products. But what’s most chilling is that the person responsible was never caught. Police investigated numerous suspects, including one man who tried to extort Johnson & Johnson, but no one was charged with the murders.

The Tylenol murders remain one of the most infamous unsolved cases in American history — a crime that reshaped everyday life yet still has no name attached to it.

14. The Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum Heist

On March 18, 1990, two men dressed as police officers talked their way into the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in Boston. Once inside, they tied up the guards and pulled off the largest art heist in U.S. history. Thirteen works, including paintings by Vermeer, Rembrandt, and Degas, vanished.

The stolen art has never been recovered, despite decades of investigation and a $10 million reward. Theories point to organized crime groups, but no arrests have ever stuck. To this day, the empty frames still hang on the museum’s walls as a reminder of what was lost.

Unlike some of the darker cases, this one doesn’t involve violence against individuals, but it still captures public imagination. How did the thieves pull it off so smoothly? And where are those priceless works now?

15. The DEATH of JonBenét Ramsey

Christmas 1996 in Boulder, Colorado. Six-year-old JonBenét Ramsey, a child beauty pageant contestant, was found dead in her family’s basement. A ransom note had been left behind, but the investigation quickly spiraled into confusion and finger-pointing.

Suspicion initially fell on her parents, John and Patsy Ramsey, but evidence never firmly tied them to the crime. Over the years, theories have ranged from an intruder breaking into the house to a family cover-up. DNA testing has advanced, but it hasn’t delivered a definitive answer.

The case became one of the most high-profile unsolved murders in American history, fueling endless media coverage, documentaries, and books. For many, JonBenét’s story is a haunting reminder of how complex investigations can be — and how some crimes may never get the closure they deserve.

Why These FAMOUS UNSOLVED Mysteries Still Grip Us

So why do these cases — some over a century old — still hold our attention? Part of it is the unknown. Human brains crave closure, and when we don’t get it, our imagination fills in the blanks. This results in conspiracy theories and endless opinions from every other person with a detective streak, keeping the discussion and speculation alive for decades. Another part is the sheer range of possibilities. From lone killers to espionage plots, each theory tells us something about our fears and our culture.

These mysteries also remind us of the limits of investigation. Even with modern forensics, some questions stay unanswered. For true crime fans, that mix of frustration and curiosity is what keeps us coming back.

Final THEORIES ON UNSOLVED MYSTERIES

Unsolved mysteries sit at the crossroads of fact and speculation. They invite us to question evidence, weigh theories, and sometimes, play detective ourselves. Whether it’s Jack the Ripper stalking the foggy streets of London or the eerie silence surrounding MH370, these stories live on because they refuse to give us closure.

And maybe that’s why we’re drawn to them — because each unsolved case is, in its own way, an open invitation to keep searching.

If you have an inner detective that craves answers, try our trivia, books, printables and games for true crime fans - they let you test and perfect your inner detective, testing and expanding your knowledge from forensics to the courtroom and everything in between!

Shop Now

REFERENCES

D.B. Cooper

1. FBI — D.B. Cooper Hijacking (FBI history page) — https://www.fbi.gov/history/famous-cases/db-cooper-hijacking. Federal Bureau of Investigation

2. FBI Vault — D.B. Cooper (FBI Records: The Vault) — https://vault.fbi.gov/D-B-Cooper%20. FBI

3. Smithsonian Magazine — After 45 years, the FBI has officially stopped looking for D.B. Cooper — https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/after-45-years-fbi-has-officially-stopped-looking-db-cooper-180959798/. Smithsonian Magazine

Hinterkaifeck (Bavaria farm murders)

1. Wikipedia — Hinterkaifeck murders (comprehensive background & sources) — https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hinterkaifeck_murders. Wikipedia

2. Mental Floss — The Chilling Story of the Hinterkaifeck Killings — https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/502044/chilling-story-hinterkaifeck-killings-germanys-most-famous-unsolved-crime. Mental Floss

3. Hinterkaifeck.ch — Dedicated research site and documents — https://www.hinterkaifeck.ch/en/start. Hinterkaifeck - Mordfall gelöst

Malaysia Airlines Flight MH370

1. Australian Transport Safety Bureau (ATSB) — MH370: search overview & official reports — https://www.atsb.gov.au/mh370. ATSB

2. ATSB — MH370 operational search reports / final report (PDF) — https://www.atsb.gov.au/mh370-pages/updates/reports (and the MH370 Data Review PDF). ATSB+1

3. AP News — MH370: summary and what we know — https://apnews.com/article/91b69d63a6bc57d6ad2bf3c1eaf6e4ed. AP News

Isdal Woman (Isdalen / Norway)

1. Wikipedia — Isdal Woman (case overview and primary sources) — https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isdal_Woman. Wikipedia

2. BBC / NRK podcast Death in Ice Valley (original reporting and episodes) — BBC podcast pages / episodes (see streaming/episode listings, also available on YouTube playlists). Example playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLz_B0PFGIn4dA6JtunVW_Gz8pNltCshwt. YouTube+1

3. AllThat’sInteresting — The Isdal Woman and her mysterious death — https://allthatsinteresting.com/isdal-woman. All That's Interesting

Amelia Earhart

1. Smithsonian Magazine — Will the search for Amelia Earhart ever end? — https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/will-search-for-amelia-earhart-ever-end-180953646/. Smithsonian Magazine

2. National Geographic — Top theories and coverage of the Earhart mystery — https://www.nationalgeographic.com/history/article/amelia-earhart-disappearance-theories-spd. National Geographic

3. Smithsonian / Air & Space — The search for Amelia Earhart (feature & analysis) — https://www.smithsonianmag.com/air-space-magazine/search-amelia-earhart-180978195/. Smithsonian Magazine

Somerton Man (Tamám Shud case)

1. ABC News (Australia) — Somerton Man identified / coverage of 2022 developments — https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-08-02/somerton-man-who-was-carl-charles-webb/101288890 and https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-07-27/somerton-man-identified/13990784. ABC+1

2. Smithsonian Magazine — Have scholars finally identified the Somerton Man? (overview of DNA/genealogy developments) — https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/have-scholars-finally-identified-the-mysterious-somerton-man-180980540/. Smithsonian Magazine

3. Wikipedia — Somerton Man (good links to primary materials and press coverage) — https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Somerton_Man. Wikipedia

Madeleine McCann

1. The Guardian — coverage of formal suspect developments and major timelines (e.g., Christian Brückner reporting) — https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/oct/11/madeleine-mccann-german-suspect-charged-sexual-offences-portugal. The Guardian

2. Metropolitan Police / Operation Grange pages — background and official disclosures about the UK review — https://www.met.police.uk/ (see Operation Grange pages / disclosure logs). Example: https://www.met.police.uk/foi-ai/metropolitan-police/disclosure-2023/may-2023/funding-on-the-madeleine-mccann-case/. met.police.uk+1

3. BBC timeline / reporting (extensive dossier & timeline material) — (BBC News timeline pages and Panorama archives). Example timeline feed: https://feeds.bbci.co.uk/news/articles/c2lkwzp0r81o. BBC Feeds

Zodiac Killer (Northern California)

1. FBI — The Zodiac Killer (FBI Records: The Vault) — https://vault.fbi.gov/The%20Zodiac%20Killer. FBI

2. CBS News — Zodiac Killer's cipher solved by amateur codebreakers (coverage of 2020 breakthrough) — https://www.cbsnews.com/news/zodiac-killer-cipher-solved-amateur-codebreakers-51-years/. CBS News

3. Ars Technica / SFGate / Chronicle reporting on ciphers and developments — e.g., https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2020/12/zodiac-killer-cipher-is-cracked-after-eluding-sleuths-for-51-years/ and https://www.sfgate.com. Ars TechnicaSFGATE

Jack the Ripper (Whitechapel murders)

1. Britannica — Jack the Ripper (encyclopaedia overview) — https://www.britannica.com/biography/Jack-the-Ripper. Encyclopedia Britannica

2. The National Archives (UK) — MEPO (Metropolitan Police) records & catalogue entries for Whitechapel / Ripper files — https://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/C1256550. discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk

3. (Optional archival resources) Jack-the-Ripper.org / Ripper archives and newspaper collections for primary press material. jack-the-ripper.org

Black Dahlia (Elizabeth Short)

1. FBI Vault — Black Dahlia (Elizabeth Short) — FBI records — https://vault.fbi.gov/Black%20Dahlia%20%28E%20Short%29%20/. FBI

2. FBI history page — Black Dahlia (summary & FBI role overview) — https://www.fbi.gov/history/famous-cases/black-dahlia. Federal Bureau of Investigation

3. People / Time / major outlets covering suspects, anniversaries and retrospectives (e.g., People piece) — https://people.com/who-killed-the-black-dahlia-elizabeth-short-8769901. People.comTIME

Dyatlov Pass Incident

1. Wikipedia overview (basic facts) Wikipedia

2. Smithsonian deep dive on theories and lasting intrigue Smithsonian Magazine

3. History.com article explaining continued mystery HISTORY

Jimmy Hoffa Disappearance

1. ClickOnDetroit summary of his vanishing and enduring legend WDIV

2. Wikipedia summary (background and unsolved history) Wikipedia

3. NBC Chicago update on the ongoing puzzle 50 years later NBC Chicago

4. People.com context on why case remains open and unresolved People.com

Tylenol Murders (1982)

1. Wikipedia entry summarizing the crime details Wikipedia

2. Time article on renewed cold-case media interest TIME

3. People.com recount of the suspect and docuseries People.com

4. Crime & Investigation article overview on the persistent mystery Crime+Investigation UK TV Channel

Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum Heist

1. Museum’s official site detailing the theft story gardnermuseum.org

2. FBI case summary of the heist Federal Bureau of Investigation

3. WGBH article on unresolved art theft decades later GBH

JonBenét Ramsey Murder

1. Wikipedia summary of the event details Wikipedia

2. FactualAmerica overview of the case’s lasting infamy Factual America Podcast

3. Sky News coverage of ongoing investigation status Sky News

4. Crime + Investigation UK article analyzing public obsession and case complexity Crime+Investigation UK TV Channel